Wednesday, January 6, 2010

doctor who audios (listened to in 2009)

Phobos (Eddie Robson)
This had some things in common with Max Warp- extreme sports on the moons of Mars while a monster that feeds on pleasure/fear makes the Doctor feel as guilty about his martyrdom as Davros did in “Journey’s End.” McGann rocked my socks but Sheridan Smith was curiously subdued.

Immortal Beloved (Jonathan Clements)
This wasn’t as ridiculous as it first seemed, and Zeus was actually extremely well-acted and well-written. The concept was all about cloning and re-zapping your mind into your younger clone’s body- very far out there and full of weird sci fi contexts, wrapped in a shell of ancient Greek mythology, and some very fresh-faced (voiced?) young actors. McGann very talky but reliable as ever.

No More Lies (Paul Sutton)
A very unusual one in both setting and structure- genuinely moving and some lovely banter between the Doctor and Lucie. The posh party setting was fun and the music lyrical- for once the back and forth structure was not particularly grating.

The Angel of Scutari (Paul Sutton)
Tolstoy and Ace as an impressive double act, the Doctor escaping with the help of a golden spoon, a hug that saves the day, a shameful secret revealed, and the phrase “I’ll explain later” used! The plot in Angel of Scutari is necessarily complicated because of the timeline issue, and though I can’t explain it in a way that makes sense, it does.

Human Resources
Best cliffhanger ever heard on Doctor Who audio. McGann was wonderful pretending to be management in a cookie-cutter company- the satire was biting but a little too cutesy in places. One of the company management staff was absolutely appalling- and so true to life!

Sisters of the Flame (Nick Briggs)
There’s no sign of Ohica, but the Sisters of Karn are trying to make a comeback. Lucie made an unlikely pairing with Rosto, appealingly (for a giant centipede) played by Alexander Siddig.

Companion Chronicles: The Glorious Revolution
A bit of circumlocutious storytelling from Jamie McCrimmon forty years after travelling with the Doctor and having his memories erased- he recalls meeting the weary monarch James II and altering the course of history despite the Doctor’s admonitions to the contrary. This is a straight historical with a good Troughton flavor to it; indeed, Fraser Hines’ invocation of Troughton is astonishingly good. It also has a very poignant ending with much in common with “Journey’s End.”

Companion Chronicles: Transit of Venus (Jacqueline Rayner)
Bizarre play with the simple premise of Ian recalling one of his adventures with the Doctor, Barbara, and Susan- this is clearly Ian’s show, though, and William Russell more than rises to the occasion. Another pure historical set in 1770 in the South Seas with Captain Cook, it’s written cannily and plays to Ian’s strengths. Rayner clearly understands the bond between Ian and Barbara and writes with that in mind.

top books 2009

[I wrote this on December 23, 2009 but couldn't post it right away]

I eschewed a strictly top ten ranked favorite books of the year because the top tier just didn’t add up to ten for me, and while all the books in the next tier were highly deserving, I couldn’t really elevate them. So we’ll just call it a conglomeration of books!

Making Cocoa for Kingsley Amis (Wendy Cope)

I’ve put poetry on this list for the first time even though I think I separated it out last year with the graphic novels. This is because I read a lot of poetry this year, and a lot of outstanding poetry. I absolutely loved this collection by Wendy Cope; she’s one of my favorite poets. I love her wit, sarcasm, self-deprecation, but she never seems to stray into all-out angst, and she’s never apologetic for being what she is.



Short Trips: How the Doctor Changed My Life (ed. Simon Guerrier)

I have separated out my Doctor Who books even though I enjoyed many of them; however, this collection of short stories was so good I really thought it deserved to be on this list. These were all the first-time writers who were judged to be good enough in the contest in 2007, and I had good things to say about almost every story. Whether or not it’s fair to compare them to writers who write Who all the time, who have skill but have perhaps lost the wide-eyed spark, this collection has many talented writers and many enjoyable stories.



The Writer’s Tale (Russell T Davies and Benjamin Cook)

This doesn’t really count as a Doctor Who book as it’s more a book about writing, and one of the best on the subject I have ever read. I’ve digested many in this genre- from Strunk & White to Natalie Goldberg- and few of them are both so candid and so encouraging. Y.A.N.A is what RTD wrote in the context of “Utopia,” but that also seems to be the message to any writer who recognizes crippling self-doubt, absurd procrastination, late night bursts of creativity, and riding by the seat of your pants as part of the literary endeavour. How comforting to know it happens, too, to the greats. Also, as far as technique for screenwriting/telewriting at least, it’s extremely useful. Also very funny and so enjoyable you’re left wanting more despite its 500+ pages.



Rapture (Carol Ann Duffy)

I’m not such a wholehearted fan of Carol Ann Duffy as I have been of Wendy Cope, though I have liked several of her poems. However, this collection was elegant, self-contained, and almost every poem touching. It charted a love affair that blossomed and then faded. It’s traditionally very hard to write love poetry in all the different stages: when we haven’t got it, it’s comparatively easy; after a point when you’re at the ecstatic stage you run out of things to say. However, I thought she covered every nuance of the stages of love with remarkable empathy and feeling.



Dear Fatty (Dawn French)

I seem to have read a lot of celebrity autobiographies this year, a genre I hitherto looked at with disdain. However, I can see their appeal (especially if well-written). Dawn French’s book really made me laugh on nearly every page. As many of these books have a “gimmick,” French’s was her life divided into chapters as letters to differentpeople significant to different parts of her life. Many letters were addressed to her father, who committed suicide when she was in her teens. I loved her letters to her daughter and to her husband Lenny Henry; my heart was hugely warmed by their love story. The Fatty of the title, by the way, is Jennifer Saunders, to whom many of the letters are also addressed.



Too Many Mothers (Roberta Taylor)

This is another sort of in the same style, but quite different in content and context. Besides, Roberta Taylor wasn’t a “celebrity” to me in the sense Dawn French or John Barrowman were- I only knew her in the context of her role in a Peter Davison Big Finish play and as a character in The Bill. So I was quite unprepared for how much I enjoyed this candid and well-structured memoir. Taylor’s is, in my opinion, the best kind of “creative nonfiction” in imagining narratives for her grandmother, mother, aunts, and other family members during the first half of the twentieth century. Subtitled “an East End childhood,” the story is often dark and bleak but also funny and a portrait of a family of strong women.



The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian (Sherman Alexie)

I have observed that books my sister recommends are either total misses with me or, less often, really succeed. This is one of the latter. I’d seen Alexie deliver a talk at UNM in 2007 but had never read anything of his. This partial memoir, partial fiction was also a partial graphic memoir with delightfully forthright illustrations. Like Alexie, Junior comes from a Reservation family, was born with water on the brain which accounts for his slightly goofy appearance, and goes to school off the Rez in order to increase his chances of ever becoming someone. The book is alternatively hilarious, sobering, and (I think) accessible even to white girls like myself.





Desolation Island (Patrick O’Brian)

What can I say? I left The Mauritius Command off last year’s list because I honestly didn’t think it was among the top ten, but Desolation Island, the fifth book in the Master and Commander series, exceeds all expectations once more. How O’Brian combines great danger and intricate plot with a convincing portrait of 19th century seamanship with superbly lifelike and irresistible characters is always a joy to read. In this adventure Captain Jack Aubrey is charged with delivering convicts to Australia but the disease, natural disaster, and mutiny he encounters tests all his powers of courage and valour. Likewise, Dr. Stephen Maturin is on board and must work his dual roles as spy and physician while coping with his constant heartbreak over Diana Villiers. Unmissable.







Runners up: Anything Goes (John & Carole Barrowman) is another in the celebrity autobiography strand, but extremely funny and for the most part, remarkably well-told. Of special mention are the photographs embedded inside. I plan to read the “sequel.” The Black Swan (Nassim Nicholas Taleb) is probably the most mind-altering book I read this year, though since it’s seated firmly in the realm of economics and probability (like Stumbling on Happiness last year, if I recall correctly) I did glaze over some sections. It is one that probably everyone should read, though like Stumbling on Happiness anyone looking for a quick fix is likely to be disappointed, as both books tell you what you can’t predict rather than how to predict anything of significance. The Bridges of Madison County was recommended by my friend Nasim as one of the books that changed her life, and indeed while I went in expecting a great deal of soppy soap opera, the book’s brevity and simplicity matched the depth of its feeling and I admit I cried while reading it. Ways of Seeing (John Berger) was another high-brow book about art criticism that nevertheless had much of relevance to say. Living to Tell the Tale (Gabriel Garcia Márquez) was possibly the best book I’ve yet read by this talented author. Yet again it was autobiographical but with the dreamlike, circumlocutious storytelling one comes to expect from mí papito rico. Anyone expecting insights into the master’s life on par with those palpable ones from RTD in A Writer’s Tale will be disappointed, but on a more general level, much of the inspiration for Márquez’s oeuvre becomes delightfully clear. Real Swansea (Nigel Jenkins) should be required reading for anyone remotely connected with the “ugly, lovely town.”



two graphic novels

I doubt you can find two graphic novels that are more dissimilar: Gene L. Yang’s semi-autobiographical American Born Chinese and Joann Sfar’s bizarre Goth fantasy Vampire Loves. But I happened to read them in the same day so here goes.

American Born Chinese reminded me immediately of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, as it was a humorous memoir of boyhood growing up living the American dream from a minority status. Though Jin Wang suffers some of the same adolescent problems with girls that Alexie’s counterpart did (surely it must be a requisite of all boys to suffer these problems?), beyond that the comparison fades. The book was a National Book Award finalist and a winner of the Michael L. Prinz Award, and its proponents laud its three seemingly disparate strands of narrative coming together with a clever twist. For me, the three strands didn’t come together quickly enough. That, however, is the only criticism I can draw up against it. I am always suitably impressed by writers/graphic artists who do everything themselves, and Yang’s style is accessible and highly readable.

The three strands are that of the Monkey King, a well-known Chinese legend; Danny and his misadventures when his stereotyped Chinese cousin comes to visit; and Jin Wang’s seventh grade friendship with Wai-Chen and everlasting crush on Amelia Harris. The thing all these have in common is trying to disguise or ignore part of one’s nature, and in the latter two examples, one’s sense of Chinese identity. I would recommend this book as it’s humorous and a quirky, appreciable read.

By contrast, you wouldn’t expect to have anything in common with Ferdinand the Vampire in Vampire Loves, but the dark humor and irony in Sfar’s signature style makes characters like vampires, wailers, wraiths, mandragoras, tree men and so on have the exact same relationship problems you’d find on Friends. Well, maybe not quite the exact same ones. Sfar is recycling many characters that have appeared in his other books, which number over 100, including the Little Vampire series, so it may not have been the best time for me to jump into his universe. Nevertheless, despite the weirdness and ghoulishness, this crowd would hit it off with the cast of Being Human and it’s sort of this combination of the nightmare and the mundane that makes Vampire Loves a fast, jaunty read.

Ferdinand is a shy, retiring, “old-fashioned” vampire who hasn’t quite hit it off with the Goth culture in his Vilna residence. “Young” Goth vampire Aspirine wants to get inside his coffin (no, really) but he prefers her older sister Ritaline. His real love, the tree-girl Lani, seems to have no concept of monogamy; on an ocean liner, he has an exciting adventure with a Werewolf and a female wraith. My favorite story was with the Japanese student in the Louvre who finds Ferdinand there and accidentally knocks him out with her Polaroid. While it doesn’t pay to think too carefully about the undead, the living, and the fantastical all wanting to fool around together, purely on the surface, the drawings are cute. And it’s another that’s written and drawn by the same person!

the end of time (SPOILERS)

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1/1/10 “The End of Time”

The story never ends. –Ood Sigma

I have to admit I liked this better than “Waters of Mars”—though to be the be-all, end-all event that it claimed to be, it would have had to top “Utopia,” which it didn’t, in my opinion. I think, with rare exceptions, RTD is at his best when he’s being concise: writing over two (or more) episodes tends to dilute his character-driven and narrative power. I guess we won’t get to observe more on this theme (at least not in the near future), as the Vast Toffee will next wow us!

As hinted by RTD, the opening scenes were dark and quite divorced from the scene with the idiotic Doctor saying aloha to Ood Sigma. The “Narrator,” who we quickly learned was the President of Gallifrey (a Rassillon if not the Rassillon), told us that the people of Earth all “had bad dreams.” Somehow this struck me as a very Lord of the Rings-type thing to say! But, being human, they forgot their nightmares in the light of day. At the same time, a troubled Wilf walked into a church. A character in a Doctor Who story walking into a church in a reverent manner?! Okay, I’m being facetious. The “legend of the blue box” was intriguing—I loved the notion of the TARDIS being reproduced in a (presumably) medieval stained glass window. Certainly the “sainted physician” story was there to introduce the Mysterious Time Lady figure and give us an idea of how crucial to events Wilf would prove. However, I wish they’d either scrapped it altogether or developed it—it didn’t really seem to make much difference to any of the rest of the story!

As I noted, yes, I found the scene with the Doctor arriving on the Planet of the Ood stooopid. Once the Doctor calmed down (though I liked the idea of him “naming a galaxy Alison”—though why didn’t he do all of the stuff he does at the end of this story in this prelude?), Ood Sigma brought him to some mystical Ood. As they chanted, I thought, “Man, too many people are returning!” Still, you can see the Christmas-y theme: Ood Sigma seems to be playing the part of Marley and the other Ood the Spirits for the Doctor’s Scrooge. “The king is in his countinghouse.” There’s some exposition about the end of the Master, in case you didn’t watch that bit. Aaaaand the hand model is revealed to be . . . a prison warden! So much for our theories about the Rani, grumble.

And speaking of disappointment, the resurrection of the Master scene was a waste of time. It didn’t make any sense and cheapened Lucy Saxon’s mystery. Lucy being held in a sort of Chicago-esque prison and forced to participate in a ritualized revivification of the Master was tough enough to believe. How they did it made no sense at all (I realize, of course, that the credulity of ever bringing the Master back is tentative—yet this was on par with the way the TV Movie’s Master was executed by the Daleks and then turned into goop!). Why this particular group of Macbeth-like witches wanted to do it (“the secret books of Saxon”??) is even murkier. But resurrect him they did, apparently causing Lucy’s death (in a rather Raiders of the Lost Ark-like scene)—her contribution was to retard his regeneration but I wasn’t clear how. (Was it by causing him to be skeletal and therefore hungry all the time?)

I’ve written that something was like V for Vendetta, but I can’t remember what! At Mr Naismith’s mansion, something sinister is going on which he has prepared as a present for his daughter: it’s a hint of Torchwood: Children of Earth plus “The Lazarus Experiment.” David Harewood is wasted as the character is never given much chance to develop and merely leaves the audience reeling, trying to take in all these characters as well as the Doctor and Wilf worriedly puttering around. (I noticed at one point there was a van that said Sparrow Lane on it . . . I thought this might turn out to be significant later, something to do with Sally Sparrow, but as far as I could tell it wasn’t.)

Like most other people, I found the hungry, homeless, emo Master quite entertaining. (He summons the Doctor with a very obvious four knocks on an oil drum.) There was perhaps a hint of “Survival” in seeing the Time Lord reduced to his most animal instincts. However, I thought more of Wolf from The 10th Kingdom: “I am sooooooo hungry!” could easily become: “Bacon sizzling away on an iron frying pan! Baste it! Roast it! Toast it! Nibble it! Chew it! Bite right through it! Wobble it! Gobble it! Wrap it ‘round a couple of chickens and I am ravenous!” As for the Master’s acquired powers—as Jamie put it, we’re not quite sure when or how he started being able to shoot fireballs from his hands or take giant leaps through the air (a couple of times I had to control my laughter as it really reminded me of a video game). However, his stalking and eating homeless people in “wastelands of London” (wherever they may be!)[1] was genuinely chilling and Master-like: somehow the pulling back to see the skeletal remains of the vendors made me think of some of the 1970s Master stories—and it was quite scary. Then the Master gets kidnapped by Naismith. What? Why?

On the other side of the spectrum we have Wilf finding the Doctor with his OAP friends aka the Gray Cloak operation—again, I wish they’d been developed or left out. Minnie the Menace could have been a rounder, more appealing character (rather than just the woman who goosed David Tennant!)—for a long time I thought “The End of Time” was going to be an adaptation of the Gary Russell book Beautiful Chaos. Certainly when I saw Wilf and the Doctor being filmed in the Kardomah in Swansea over the May Bank Holiday weekend last year, I could tell that a serious discussion between the two characters was going on within the confines of the café (at Christmastime, clearly, by the décor). I also had been told Catherine Tate had been filmed outside, leading me to believe she had a peripheral role (ie, she and the Doctor didn’t meet) which again suggested Beautiful Chaos to me (go read it, by the way). So certainly “The End of Time” peaked early for me when I saw the scene I was expecting and looking forward to, though it had nothing to do with the Gary Russell book.

For many, this was the most touching scene of the story, and for me it was clearly the highlight of the first part. When RTD uses his delicacy of touch like this, and Bernard Cribbins and David Tennant play off each other in such a way, you get a winner! “We keep on meeting, Wilf,” the Doctor says ominously. The Doctor’s fear and frustration with his impending regeneration (so different from the Fourth Doctor’s attitude!) sounds suspiciously like sour grapes from David Tennant (if he had them): “some new man comes sauntering in . . .” Meanwhile Wilf fills us in on the Noble-Temple (er, Temple-Noble) marriage[2]. Unfortunately their impending matrimony will be plagued with debts if Wilf is to be believed. “She’s so sad but she can’t remember why. . . . She’s making do.” This is a topic I would have liked to have seen explored more, actually! I suppose, in a way, Donna’s malaise relates to all human kind’s malaise—after all, didn’t the Narrator say everyone was having bad dreams but forgetting them, but still tinged with menace in the waking world? Perhaps that’s commenting on all of us in the realm of reality: sad, but we don’t know why. We want to be touched by something as extraordinary as the Doctor but we can’t, we aren’t, we live our mundane lives. Perhaps that’s why we’re watching the show in the first place!

After this, Wilf becomes a proper companion as he jumps into the TARDIS—“I thought it would be cleaner”—and I am happy because Tennant dons the brown suit to die in, which I like much better than the blue anyway. (So sue me, I’m shallow.) The rabid Master scares the schnikey out of Naismith—“you taste great!”—and the more fool him, to think he can manipulate the Master instead of the other way around. The scientists, meanwhile, who have been working on Naismith’s Stargate thingee are revealed to be Vinvotchee—more Meglos or Majenta Pryce? The Master reveals his most outrageous (and characteristically egotistical) fiendish plot yet: to use the nanobot technology of the Gate to change every human on Earth into duplicates of himself! I had to grin at the audacity of this and the horror it created in the viewers, the Doctor, Wilf, Donna, and the Vinvotchee (the only ones left on Earth not turned into mini-Masters). In particular one has to sympathize deeply with John Simm who played all of these parts in a variety of ridiculous outfits—especially the Chiswick scenes.

As if this wasn’t enough, the Time Lords next come in and it’s a moment of fanwank bliss (at least, I would imagine!) for anyone who was dazzled by the Gallifrey presented in “The Sound of Drums.” I was dazzled, anyway! Their president is played by Timothy Dalton (a curious casting choice!) but I was more concerned—to the point of mild obsession!—with the “children” standing in the background covering their faces. I thought for a brief moment it was the child Master and the child Doctor covering their eyes from staring into the Untempered Schism.

The beginning of the second part opened with the startling image of the Citadel of Gallifrey on fire as it crashed into Earth—sadly the first fifteen minutes of this had me fidgeting restlessly—so much exposition and me being aware that time was running out! The décor of this version of Gallifrey reminded me more of Star Wars The Phantom Menace than “The Deadly Assassin”—nevertheless, the same color scheme, it seems to me, was observed. Presumably due to lack of budget, though, the Time Lord High Council was taking place in a vacuum with only a few Councillors on hand (though I suppose that’s explained away with it being the darkest hour of the Time War).

The Visionary reminded me of a Hopi kachina design I saw once, and also for one split-second I thought she had evolved (or devolved?) from Dalek Caan—it was the same kind of insane cackling prophecies! “This is only the furthest edge of the Time War but at the center, millions die.” I was impressed that this entire episode managed to leave most of the mystery and canonicity of the Time War untouched so that it can be detailed—or not—later. I like the mystery and leaving it that way. Rather abruptly, the President disposed of his dissenting voice—“thank you for your opinion”—by vaporizing her with his resurrection glove (at least we assume—though Jamie wondered whether it might be the Hand of Omega!). As their solution the Time Lords naturally turn to “two children of Gallifrey,” “the enmity of ages.” Rather wearily that turns their attention to Earth (again).

Meanwhile on Earth everyone has been Master-ified (including a national army in Beijing, interestingly). Donna is having to deal with this and is having a “metacrisis.” Frankly, I don’t know what the point of her storyline is at all—she’s put briefly in peril and then taken out of it again. The Doctor, as ever, tries to persuade the Master away from his evil deeds. “You don’t need to own the universe.” The Master is hoping to use the amplification of his multiple selves to pinpoint the source of the never-ending drums in his head. “I don’t know what I’d be without that noise.” Then the Doctor/Master slashers go crazy as they are given plenty of material for their fan fic. :-/ Wilf is bewildered, the Doctor smug once he and Wilf are able to escape with the help of the Vinvotchee. “God bless the cactuses!” cries Wilf as they are teleported (or whatever the term is) onto their space ship (which looks kind of like Serenity to my untrained eye). “Cacti!” There’s a barely amusing scene of the Doctor being tossed down the stairs in a gurney (a nod to the scenes of Patrick Troughton in the wheelchair in “The Two Doctors”?).

As the Master’s (Masters’?) plan takes him to the source of the drumming, in narrative terms the Time Lords are just coming up with the idea of implanting the sound in his head from childhood. The Glorious Revolution does a better job of explaining time paradox than this (or I) do, but basically, this happened because it had to happen. (Strangely enough that was the line of logic I was pursuing at the end of “Parting of the Ways” to explain a) Bad Wolf; b) the love between the Doctor and Rose.) In the downtime Wilf is again approached by the Mysterious Time Lady who tells him to arm himself “old soldier.” “He never carries guns,” he says of the Doctor. When Wilf talks to the Doctor, he comes up with the single most disturbing line of the story: “Do you think he [the Master] changed them in their graves?” The scene that follows goes on a bit long, IMHO, and most of the ground was already covered in the scene in the Kardomah. “I’m older than you,” the Doctor says, giving his age (to our consternation) as 906. There’s an odd line about the Doctor wishing Wilf was his dad. I enjoy the sentiment, but it makes about as much sense as the Tenth Doctor telling the Fifth Doctor “you were my Doctor!” Nevertheless, Wilf is taking the part of devil’s advocate and pleads with the Doctor to “kill him first.” The Doctor refuses—“I’ve taken lives, manipulated people into taking their own.” “Don’t you dare put his life before theirs!”

The Master has tried to destroy the Vinvotchee ship (and the Doctor—“we don’t need him”) with missiles. This gives us probably the best sequence of this episode: Wilf in a X-Wing-type fighter—delightful. Once he finds out that the source of the Master’s drumming is the Time Lords who are on their way (impossibly or no), the Doctor, in “Voyage of the Damned” mode, doesn’t plan on stopping the ship’s downward velocity into the Naismith mansion. In the end the Doctor spares his allies but jumps into a glass ceiling and falls at the feet of the Master and the Time Lord. The President greets them, “Lord Doctor, Lord Master” (which just sounds naff). The Master gets possessive over his “work” and then has the audacity to expect to turn every Time Lord into himself! Sounds very Delgado somehow! Rassillon (for it is he, apparently) enacts a good fix and returns all the humans to their normal selves. “I get the credit [for bringing the Time Lords back]!” the Master snarls. Gallifrey the planet is about to submerge the Earth, and understandably frightened people try to escape. Wilf demonstrates selfless heroism that is on par with anything the Doctor’s ever done (and it’s another case of don’t show a radiation chamber you aren’t going to use). “My kind of world!” the Master cries crazily. “The final sanction—free of time.” “Take me with you!” the Master begs. “You are diseased—a disease of your own making.”

I’m not the first, and I won’t be the last, to compare the Doctor here to Hamlet. (And not just because David Tennant played him—I made the comparison with Tom Baker’s Doctor in light of “Genesis of the Daleks.”) He’s got a gun and he can’t decide whether to use it on the Master or the Time Lords. “He’s to blame, not me,” says the Master. “The link is inside my head!” As the Doctor tries to make his decision, one of the “children” peeks out from behind her hands. It’s the Mysterious Time Lady, variously ascribed to be the Doctor’s mother, Romana, Ace (I thought perhaps Donna someday in the future because of the red hair), crying. “Get out of the way,” the Doctor says to the Master. He shoots the Gate thingee which causes the Time Lords to get sucked back into the vortex or whatever. “Get out of the way,” the Master responds, using his thunderbolt powers to beat back Rassillon. Presumably he gets sucked into the vortex with them. I did actually quite like this bit—I suppose it was a little staged (what am I saying, of course it’s staged, it’s drama!) but overall it was a nice character back-and-forth.

I knew it was a fakeout! I screamed to myself when Wilf knocked four times on the glass of his radiation chamber. I know various people have complained that the performance here isn’t particularly Doctor-ish—he’s never reacted to regeneration this way before. Think of the resigned quality of the Fourth Doctor seeing the Watcher—he knew what was coming but he certainly didn’t rail about it like this. I suppose a different, more emotive Doctor will react differently. The last two regenerations have been an echo of Five into Six: namely, giving his life for a companion. Fake out #2 I think fooled us all, when the Doctor crumpled into a ball inside the radiation chamber, surely announcing his imminent regeneration (I began to cry, of course).

Perhaps the most controversial section of “The End of Time”—the “epilogue” of sorts. This all put me in mind of the end of Return of the King. Purists would have it that all those endings had to be included because they were all part of the book. Ordinary cinema-goers were twitching convulsively or had fallen asleep. I was in the spectrum somewhere in between—I think at the time I saw it (the Albuquerque midnight premiere, mind you) I was both very tired and also crying and not wanting it to end. In any case, all those sort of resolving of loose ends were necessary or weren’t—depending on your perspective. For most I reckon these resolving of loose ends weren’t necessary. I had fun with them, up to a point. Certainly RTD saw this as his swansong as did David Tennant, so in terms of packing away that universe it was perhaps in their best interests, as they saw it.

I was shocked but pleased by Martha and Mickey being married and fighting Sontarans together. Obviously like everyone else I wondered what had happened to Martha’s fiancé and what caused this abrupt course of events. My mind immediately went into fan fic writer mode to connect all the dots, but I suspect by the time I write my ideas down it will be too late and Torchwood series 4 will invalidate all my theories. The scene with Captain Jack (presumably post-“Children of Earth”) in the “Mos Eisley cantina” (personally I was thinking of Quark’s) was similarly unexpected. I think the accusation that RTD just wanted it in so he could reuse Russell Tovey may hold some water, but at the same time I won’t deny I cracked a smile. “Allons-y, Alonso,” indeed.

I think I started crying again when “Verity Newman” was signing her book, A Journal of Impossible Things. I won’t necessarily defend my actions. Clearly, the rational side of my brain dismissing all of this as self-indulgent and fan wanky was not communicating with the emotional part of my brain (sixteen years old) which was producing the tears. The Doctor then saw Donna’s wedding from afar and produced a winning lottery ticket to solve all their financial woes (I had a private grin to myself). Oh, and then I really started crying when the Doctor decided to do “1996” more or less. I can’t defend this, really—it just seemed to me that it was a nice way of bringing things full circle. It all started on the Powell Estate with the 2005 Christmas Special (a year before I saw it!) for the Tenth Doctor. “I bet you’re going to have a really great year.” Despite all the sap, I think Ood Sigma had a point: the story never ends for us fans. Surely all these years have proven that if nothing else?

The Doctor regenerates, alone, in the TARDIS, which I don’t think has happened before—he’s always had a companion by his side (except in the case of the Seventh Doctor who was in a hospital, and we don’t know how Eight regenerated). The screaming and explosions—well, that’s one way to go! I know new Doctors’ first lines rarely endear themselves to viewers, but it wasn’t the lines so much as the delivery that disappointed me. It seemed, forgive me, the same manic energy as the Tenth Doctor. Like most others, I’ll be happy to see Matt Smith tackle the role—provided he brings something new to it as all his predecessors have done. I was unclear how his hair made him suspect he was a girl??

As someone said to me, it will be difficult to judge how cut up we are about the depature of our Doctor of three-ish years, as it will take awhile to sink in that he’s really gone (what with the glut of David Tennant programs on TV recently, not that I’m complaining). I will miss him—I cried a lot I have to admit, but I was emotional for other reasons at the time. I also cried a lot during “Parting of the Ways”—so I think it will all be okay.

Thursday, November 12, 2009

the angel of scutari

Unfortunately my experience with Big Finish has been spotty; like most people I can’t afford to buy a subscription. Jamie bought me Angel of Scutari, which I’d been eyeing anyway, as it relates to one of our projects. I hadn’t gotten around to listening to it until now, not due to disinterest, but due to lack of time and wanting to listen to it on a long coach journey. I just had a long coach journey so I managed to listen to it! In the past I haven’t done very good Big Finish reviews because I haven’t taken good notes. Ta-da—good notes!

I have to admit that the very first scenes did not impress me, which is a shame as I really liked the play by the end. Reflecting on it, I don’t see how Paul Sutton could have written the first few scenes any other way—they were necessary for the way the story panned out—yet I wonder if another writer would have handled it differently. The introduction sets the scene: it’s 1853 and William Russell (not the one who played Ian!), the London Times’ correspondent, writes about the Charge of the Light Brigade from the Crimea. Back in London, General Kitchen (Alex Lowe) gives a rather heavy-handed appearance of desperation and cynicism: “Sebastopol should never have happened.” Also in London is “Miss Nightingale,” demanding from her friend Sir Sidney Herbert “when are you sending me to the Scutari?” The whole interaction between the two is kind of clunky; Florence wants to go nurse, her friend wants her to get married, “I can live without love—I cannot live without my work.” Intriguingly, she will be joining Thomas Hector Schofield—the “angel of Scutari.” Cue theme music!

Audio conventions are found in abundance, though they can be forgiven. “This is it, then?” asks Ace, giving the Doctor the chance to tell us where they are (the Crimea). “This is a ship,” Ace tells us, too. Unfortunately they seem to have landed in the middle of action on a Russian ship. Poor Ace keeps getting badly injured, and the Russian soldier who first threatens to shoot her, then helps to save Ace (as the “blue box” goes over the side), is almost annoying. Until we find out that he’s a young Lev Tolstoy (John Albasiny). The Doctor is separated from Ace, who ends up in hospital with the amusing, bet-making writer. “Are you trying to chat me up, Lev?”
This is when the time travel comes in, and while it takes a lot of concentration to keep up, it is worth it. A few months earlier (in the Crimean timeline) Hex, the Doctor, and Ace land in the British army barracks. The Doctor lets Hex wander—“he knows exactly where he is and when.” However, in the later timeline, the Doctor gets attacked by William Russell who wants to shoot him—even though from the Doctor’s perspective they’ve never met. End part 1.

Part two consists of Hex wanting to muck in and help the soldiers in the Crimea, before Florence (Jenny Spark) gets there—Ace lets him use her spare key to get supplies from the TARDIS. In the other timeline, Russell has the Doctor, Ace is still with Tolstoy, and we don’t know where Hex is. The Doctor debates with Russell over the ethics of the war. In the earlier timeline, Ace is flabbergasted Hex has turned into “St Francis of Assisi .” In the later timeline, Hex sees the TARDIS chopped up for firewood! He’s tongue-tied when at last he meets his idol Florrie. “Your implication is lascivious,” she retorts to William Russell, who has insinuating that she and her traveling companion, Kitchen, who was meant to have killed the Doctor as a collaborator way back in the first few minutes of the play, is her sugar daddy. (“You are pretty hot,” Hex says.) There’s another slightly anti-climactic cliffhanger.

In part three, in the earlier timeline, the Doctor is imprisoned in a Russian dungeon and meets a thoroughly grey Nicholas I. Meanwhile Ace is still with Tolstoy and overjoyed that the TARDIS hasn’t been destroyed because she can still read Russian. In the later timeline Hex escapes from Russell by giving him tea that “tastes like the inside of a Muscovite’s britches.” He finds Nightingale and confesses his doubts about traveling with the Doctor and Ace—confesses his feelings for Ace but “I’m not so sure anymore.” “You kiss her . . . a lot?” “She’d break my arm if I tried!” Ace is also being a bit romantic with Tolstoy, too, helping him win his bet with a kiss—before she knocks him out and tries to make a getaway.

Part four sees Tolstoy and Ace as an impressive double act, the Doctor escaping with the help of a golden spoon, a hug that saves the day, a shameful secret revealed, and the phrase “I’ll explain later” used! Ace is also charmingly jealous of Nightingale—“if you stay out of my face, mush”—rather like the fact she and Rose didn’t get along in “The Ten Doctors” comic.

The plot in Angel of Scutari is necessarily complicated because of the timeline issue, and though I can’t explain it in a way that makes sense, it does. Make sense. As this is a radio play, the entire Crimean War has to be distilled into a handful of recurring characters. This is easy with Tolstoy and Nightingale since they’re in the action all the time, and particularly with Tolstoy, are charmingly written and a lot of fun—they hold our attention. Nightingale as written is a bit of a wet noodle, but probably true to life. I think the last audio play I heard with Sophie Aldred in it was The Settling, similar to this in several ways, including it being about a brutal war, the fact it was all historical and no aliens, and the way the Doctor and the companions got separated along the way. The play, though dark, was not quite as hard-hitting as The Settling. On the plus side, however, the Ace here seemed much brighter, younger, and I could see her uttering each line. Sylvester McCoy is a wonderful radio actor and, as in The Settling, he was often in situations where he didn’t know whether his companions would live or die.

There is no romanticism of war in The Angel of Scutari, with the trivialities of the Crimea presented solidly against the desperate conditions of the hospitals, which Hex tries so hard to ameliorate. Nevertheless it is quite funny in parts and contains many a witty line. As ever there are fantastic soundscapes and editing, and hearing this particular theme tune really takes me back to my childhood.

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Desolation Island

‘You cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs,’ said Jack quickly, before the chance should be lost forever. ‘Ha, ha, Stephen, what do you say to that?’
‘I might say something about pearls before swine—the pearls being these priceless eggs, if you follow me—were I to attempt a repartee in the same order of magnitude.’
‘I did not fag all the way up here to be insulted about my wit, which, I may tell you, is more generally appreciated in the service than you may suppose,’ said Jack.

As you know if you’ve read me, I read a Patrick O’Brian book in the Master and Commander series every year. Just one, every year. 2009 was the fifth book, Desolation Island. The reason I measure out my exposure to these books is that I am convinced they are the best historical fiction ever written, and every time I read one of the books it makes me immeasurably happy and intellectually fulfilled. Even though the last book, The Mauritius Command, was incrementally lesser than its predecessors (particularly HMS Surprise, my favorite of the ones I’ve read so far) Desolation Island is certainly back up in the stratosphere. So good—I have no words.

Well, me being me, I actually do. Here’s the review .

Like the two previous books, Desolation Island starts on land with Captain Jack Aubrey, his wife Sophie and their three children, her mother Mrs Williams, Dr Stephen Maturin, Barret Bonden (ship’s coxswain), and Preserved Killick (steward)—one big happy family in Ashgrove Cottage. O’Brian has always written Sophie extremely well, and though she gets comparatively little disclosure in this book, O’Brian conveys Sophie’s complex feelings toward her husband (who she loves deeply, who she has to govern to a certain extent on land, and who she worries about while he is at sea), and toward one of her best friends, Stephen. Despite their domestic bliss, Jack’s get-rich-quick schemes are dubious and almost draw him into a duel. Meanwhile, Mrs Williams must never be forgotten:
Most of the servants in Ashgrove Cottage were sailors, partly because of the extreme difficulty of inducing maids to stay within reach of Mrs Williams’ tongue; upon seamen, however, long inured to the admonition of the bosun and his mates, its lash fell unregarded; and in any case its virulence was much diminished, since they were men, and since in fact they kept the place as trim as a royal yacht.

There is an outrageous aside where Killick buys a wife before we return to Stephen’s secrets. (‘But if you had heard him speak of wombats—oh, just in passing, and not with any sense of ill-usage—it would have brought tears to your eyes. Oh, Jack, he is so very low.’)

The reason Stephen is so low continues to be Diana Villiers, Sophie’s cousin and a selfish, high-flying woman Stephen has loved for the better part of three novels. She has continuously rejected him, (In a brief flare of rebellion, anger, and frustration he thought of his enormous expense of spirit these last few weeks, of the mounting hope that he had indulged and fostered in spite of his judgement and their frequently violent disagreements; but the flame died, leaving not so much an active sorrow as a black and wordless desolation) but this book proves he is still desperately in love. Her spectre is invoked when Stephen is summoned on his avocation: spying. It seems Diana has been caught up in spying for the Americans and has just avoided being arrested by the Bow Street Runners. She is implicated with a Mrs Wogan, an American, who is being transported for her undercover crimes. According to Stephen’s superior, Mrs Wogan ‘writes like a cat, with every third word underlined, and cannot spell. Speaks excellent French, however, and sits a horse to admiration: no other education that can be detected.’ Due to his obsession over Diana, Stephen appears to be losing his mojo as an intelligence agent, and his superiors want him to reassert his usefulness by spying on Mrs Wogan as she is transported to the colonies—on the Leopard, a ship given to Jack to sail to New South Wales. The book wickedly tempts us with a portrait of William Bligh and never delivers!

Aboard ship, Jack is faced with a not very enjoyable task of transporting convicts (among them three women including Mrs Wogan), insubordination, and a possible Jonah. Stephen likewise must question if his heart is in spying when he starts to fall for Mrs Wogan, who physically resembles Diana, and equally he feels kinship for Michael Herapath, the American who dotes on Mrs Wogan the way Stephen dotes on Diana. Stephen, despite his misgivings, sees himself as a much superior spy: Not the slightest flicker of awareness. Either the woman was the most consummate actress or she had never heard his name. Diana, he reflected bitterly, might not have been so proud of mentioning it. SPOILERS: I spent the whole book in mortal terror that Wogan and Herapath were much more artful than they seemed, and she was going to poison Stephen or betray him or something. I was wrong! /SPOILERS

Midway through the passage, the convicts and then the crew are afflicted with gaol-fever (no idea what kind of contagious virus this would now be called) which thins out the crew and makes every man precious. Jack’s lieutenant, Grant, proves a thorn in his side, though Jack (in letters to Sophie) and Stephen (in his cipher journal) are quick to admit he has his good points : maintaining his mother and two unmarried sisters on his pay, his strong seamanship and chastity. Though “Lucky” Jack Aubrey never backs down from a fight, he does not seek out the Dutch ship Waakzaamheid. Instead, the mighty ship pursues and nearly destroys the Leopard in some of the most exciting sea battles yet described in the series. From them Jack nearly does not return alive, though the wonderful thing about Jack Aubrey is his humanity. While contemplating the Dutch captain dressed in black, ‘I wonder,’ thought Jack, ‘whether it is just an odd chance, or whether we killed some relative of his? His boy, perhaps, dear God forbid.’ He is gracious and compassionate to his enemy: [destruction of the Waakzaamheid] filled him with a kind of sorrow, a strange abiding grief.

Jack has a virtuoso role to play in this book, as the rest of the story shows him commanding his ship out of sea-fields of icebergs (some of the most startling imagery the books have yet produced), near-mutiny, Desolation Island, a confrontation with an American whaler, and ultimately he keeps his conviction, his cool head, his faith in Stephen, his love for Sophie, and his mastery of the sea.

Despite this, I found the book spending a lot more time in Stephen’s head than it did Jack’s, which is somewhat unusual as both characters have been given equal attention in the past. I have no complaints as I love Stephen deeply and would suffer no hesitancy if he ever asked me to marry him! Anyone who has ever loved without that love being returned will recognize themselves in Stephen, and my heart aches for him through most of the book. His frustration with the walls of falseness he has to put up in order to pursue his espionage is combated by his opium habit. Despite all this cynicism, the book ended on a much more romantic, compassionate, humane, and even sentimental note that I expected; it was really a pleasant surprise and a joy to behold.

I think resolution to Stephen’s Diana problem will at last be achieved in the next book.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Poetry on Tap

“A Wild Gush from Poetry on Tap”

CARDIFF, WALES – Poets PETER FINCH and LESLIE MCMURTRY will read their latest work at the new Poetry on Tap reading series on Sunday, 15 November, upstairs at the Promised Land, Windsor Place (off Queen St), from 2pm.

PETER FINCH is the author of several collections of poetry and local history, including The Welsh Poems and Real Cardiff. He will be reading new and previously unread poems from his forthcoming Seren collection ZEN CYMRU. Swansea-based upcoming poet LESLIE MCMURTRY, originally from Albuquerque, New Mexico and recently announced the winner of Rev. Eli Jenkins' Five and Country Senses Poetry Competition, will also read.

The evening also includes an open mic section. Entry £4, and £2 for open mic readers.

Poetry on Tap is a monthly poetry and spoken word series co-curated by Ivy Alvarez and Mab Jones, providing a showcase for electric experimentation and lively risk-taking through poetry, with exciting and uncommon pairings between poets and spoken word artists. Supported by Academi.
###
ENDS
In brief:
What: Poetry on Tap, a monthly poetry/spoken word series
Who: Poets PETER FINCH & LESLIE McMURTRY feature
Where: The Promised Land, Windsor Place (off Queen St)
When: Sunday, 15 November 2009, start 2pm
How much: £4 / £2 open mic readers

Notes for Editors:
Ivy Alvarez is the author of Mortal (Washington, DC: Red Morning Press, 2006). Her poetry is featured in anthologies, journals and new media in many countries, including Best Australian Poems 2009 (Black Inc), Brilliant Coroners (Laupe House) and Letters to the World (Red Hen Press).

Mab Jones is a poet, comic, writer, performer and spoken word artist. Winner of the John Tripp Spoken Poetry Audience Award and semi-finalist in the Funny Women and Radio 4 National Poetry Slam competitions, her first poetry book is forthcoming in 2010.

Poetry on Tap Blog: http://poetryontap.wordpress.com/
Website: http://poetryontap.webs.com/